For example, just one orca whale is worth about $10 million in the captivity industry,104 which also pushes establishments to force female orcas to birth calves earlier or more quickly than is healthy for the mothers or calves.105, 106 The yearly revenue of the zoo and aquarium industry in the US as a whole is over $2 billion.107 Zoos, aquariums, parks, and other captive establishments are businesses that have to attract visitors in order to make money for their shareholders; for each animal they releaseespecially the animals who are the most popular attractionsthey will lose visitors and thus lose money.108, The profitability of animals is also a contributor to the mistreatment of Social vs. medical egg freezing: Whats the difference? psychological well-being.154 Frequent examples of MMPAMarine Mammal Protection Act; a federal law that limits the taking or Today's news is riddled with tragic news of deaths of several creatures in zoos. This can then lead to serious psychological harm as well as other issues for the calf.175 Maternal neglect in captivity has been documented among a wide variety of species besides orcas, including sloth bears,176 tenrecs,177 gazelles,178 and baboons.179. Wild animals kept in zoos, aquariums, marine parks and theme parks, and other types of captive establishments endure severe mistreatment, both due to the inherently stressful nature of captivity as well as certain conditions within these facilities that exacerbate the mistreatment. euthanasia in captive elephants.180 Additionally, many apes suffer A more sustainable solution to free a greater number of animals from the mistreatment of captivity is placing animals in sanctuaries. Zoos accredited by the A.Z.A. animals.2 They are also in charge of enforcing the requirements Method 1 Getting Involved to Help the Animals 1 Contact your local zoos and push them to improve their standards. dolphins and orcas often experience oral degradation, which means that their The way animals initially find themselves in zoos is that they are kidnaped from nature and then brought to zoos. unnoticed by those who have the power to enforce regulations, this allows For example, 42% of studies in a meta-analysis found increased GC A significant contributor to the widespread mistreatment of wild animals in captivity is how human society as a whole has historically viewed and continues to view animals as largely existing for human benefit and entertainment. Tied up and tortured. Display would be incidental. brief. it can breed Preferred Citation: Coleman, Madison. The suspect, Davion Irvin, was arrested and charged with multiple counts of animal cruelty 2.. Zoo Standards Place where wild animals and sometimes domesticated animals are held are exhibited in captivity Some zoos can specialize (primates, large cats, etc.) She somehow got over the 12-foot wall surrounding her 1,000-square-foot enclosure and attacked one of the teenagers, killing him. A 2000 survey of U.S. and Canadian zoos found that nearly half of respondents were giving their gorillas Haldol, Valium or another psychopharmaceutical drug. The Association of Zoos and Aquariums, which . Audubon Aquarium. Dolphins at the Miami Seaquarium have also been Plant and Health Inspection Services (APHIS).7) protects zoo animals88 and the Marine Mammal Protection Act 96% of elephants in entertainment facilities are treated poorly. Wild animals can also face mistreatment through forced breeding programs. According to Newsweek, the report aptly titled The show cant go on has found that more than 75 percent of these zoos and aquariums across the world offer their customers some type of animal-visitor interaction that goes against the very guidelines WAZA has provided them with. A new investigative survey by the nonprofit group World Animal Protection (WAP) uncovered some disturbing realities of animal mistreatment in a wide swath of the 1,241 venues belonging to the World Association of Zoos and Aquariums (WAZA). I dont see any problem with holding animals for display, Mr. Ashe told me. In his Animal Park, which opened in 1907 in Hamburg, he designed cages that didnt look like cages, using moats and artfully arranged rock walls to invisibly pen animals. governments and institutionsand partially due to the negative stigma that She is especially passionate about refugee and immigrant issues, women's rights, voluntourism, mass incarceration, and police brutality. According to Omaha's Henry Doorly Zoo and Aquarium, officials at the zoo learned the cheetah had escaped around 3:40 p.m. Zoos, aquariums and circuses are all popular entertainment venues, but behind the scenes, cruelty is sparking the animal rights debate. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/11/opinion/zoos-animal-cruelty.html, Photographs by Peter Fisher for The New York Times. elephants do not have large enough enclosures and the floors of their to stress.148 Evidence of this chronic stress is also seen in AZAAmerican Zoo and Aquarium Association; a federal body that sets voluntary include pacing, chewing on the edges of tanks or enclosures, regurgitating But that day of release never quite seems to come. aneurysm from the force. This psychological harm can result from essentially any form of mistreatment that has been discussed thus far. by other elephants, which significantly exceeds the level of aggression In recent years, the welfare of animals kept in zoos & aquariums has come under increasingly greater scrutiny. 4 STATES Do not currently have laws on keeping dangerous wild animals as pets: Alabama, Nevada, North Carolina, South Carolina and Wisconsin. It should be noted that many wild animals are aggressive Alas, theres plenty of heartbreaking evidence that many are not. World Animal Protections report describes venues that offered encounters where visitors can stroke, kiss, and cuddle with big cats, shows where humans surf on the backs of dolphins, and performances in which elephants paint pictures with their trunks. They want to be free to walk, run, fly, climb, hunt and have families. zoochosisA condition in which a zoo animal frequently exhibits stereotypic stereotypic behaviorRepetitive behaviors induced by frustration, repeated attempts to cope, World Animal ProtectionZoo DAmneville in France offers customers shows such as these, where once free-roaming tigersare made to mimic their trainer for an audience. stereotypiesRepetitive behaviors induced by frustration, repeated attempts to cope, Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Twitter (@NYTopinion) and Instagram. standards for animal care in zoos and aquariums and accredits organizations March 1, 2023. ramming his head into the wall on two separate occasions, sustaining a serious self-mutilative behaviorclassified as Zoos generally hold a variety of animals for public display, also known as "zoological parks." On the other hand, sea-parks, hold fish and amphibians. many of them stop using the device after a few days or even a few hours, and Although some captive establishments certainly do dedicate more of their time and resources to conservation and education,103 the impact of the captive industry as a whole is extremely minimal because its main purpose is entertainment. That was certainly found to be the case in SeaWorld Antonio, as well. Id like to think these kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. It is very common for captive animals to die earlier than is normal due to the stressful and unhealthy conditions in captive establishments. Partially due to the lack of accurate and regular record-keeping by Terms & Conditions Cookies Policy Privacy Policy. which has not ever been documented in the wild.170, Another indicator of psychological harm to captive animals is when mothers are neglectful or aggressive toward their infants due to improper breeding practices. health issues have been found to persist even after animals have been released and increasing psychological well-being. of animal-visitor interaction experience that went against the guidelines captive establishment.183, 184, 185, Many animals also suffer from physiological issues due to prolonged stress But many animals clearly show us that they do not enjoy captivity. choose to follow its guidelines.5 Many suffer from arthritis and other joint problems from standing on hard surfaces; elephants kept alone become desperately lonely; and all zoo elephants suffer mentally from being cooped up in tiny yards while their free-ranging cousins walk up to 50 miles a day. depending on the species and on the captive situation. Because of the inadequate tank sizes and depths, cetaceansMarine mammals such as whales and dolphins.1, and great apes.208 Although some species demonstrate high infant as well as tuberculosis in elephants, have been found to be tied to This oral degradation puts the cetaceansMarine mammals such as whales and dolphins.1 A gorilla named Togo at the Toledo Zoo used his incredible strength to bend the bars of his cage. frequent mating between relatives.13. WAZA cannot enforce these guidelines; zoos and aquariums voluntarily join WAZA and choose to follow its guidelines.5, AZAAmerican Zoo and Aquarium Association; a federal body that sets voluntary standards for animal care in zoos and aquariums and accredits organizations if they meet the credentials.6, AWAAnimal Welfare Act; a federal law that protects captive animal welfare by establishing standards for care. allowed the oxygen levels in the tank to drop too low.144, SeaWorld trainers are taught to believe that the tricks they are training animals to perform are simply extensions of their natural behaviorthat the animals are doing it not because they have to, but because they really want to.. Another significant contributor to the mistreatment of wild animals in Living collections were often presented in taxonomic order, with various species of the same family grouped together, for comparative study. choose to follow its guidelines. WAP notes that SeaWorld San Antonio offers shows and opportunities to swim, pet, and pose with dolphins, which respond to commands from trainers. Many animals held in captivity in these facilities continue to be bored, cramped, lonely, and unable to perform normal social behaviors. groups. Lions are made to perform in gladiator-style battles, something wholly unnatural to these captive creatures. She plans to obtain a dual graduate degree in global social work and public administration to help create, implement, and advocate for policies that will empower disadvantaged populations all over the world. Elephants figure prominently in his book, in part because they are so big that when they escape it generally makes the news. animals routine less predictable has been shown to decrease The report found that the Texas venue hosts several animal performances that are not only demeaning but potentially fairly dangerous to the animals health. results from this study. Can we bring a species back from the brink?, Video Story, A journey of the senses through Abu Dhabi, Video Story, Copyright 1996-2015 National Geographic Society, Copyright 2015-2023 National Geographic Partners, LLC. There are certain conditions within captivity, such as small enclosures and being forced to perform in shows, that can severely exacerbate the mistreatment that captive animals face. abnormal behaviors as a coping mechanism.157, 158 Though the Climate change around the world: In Postcards From a World on Fire, 193 stories from individual countries show how climate change is reshaping reality everywhere, from dying coral reefs in Fiji to disappearing oases in Morocco and far, far beyond. The others ran, and she pursued them, ignoring all other humans in her path. self-harm is that whales have been found to ram their head or body into the stereotypic behavior (all indicators of high stress levels) as compared to According to Encarta ( 2003), humans maintained big collections of the animal from the past until now. This self-harming behavior can come in the form of World Animal Protection Group Uncovers Horrible Mistreatment At Hundreds Of Zoos And Aquariums. abnormalities. often unintentional and perpetuated due to the actions and policies of the and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9 and/or CNS dysfunction. These behaviors have no apparent goal or function, health effectsand due to the fact that self-stranding is virtually unheard of This is potentially highly detrimental to their health. multitude of environmental issues.132 As of 2004, APHIS employed Jungle Cat World lost its WAZA membership last year after it resigned from Canadas Accredited Zoos and Aquariums (CAZA). A condition in which a zoo animal frequently exhibits stereotypic animals. animal care by providing the environmental stimuli necessary for optimal The A.Z.A.s policies allow for the euthanasia of animals, but the president of the association, Dan Ashe, told me, its very rarely employed by his member institutions. For example, since Unauthorized use is prohibited. In the case of animal abuse in zoos, statistics reveal that most of the world's zoos and aquariums offer visitors some interaction with animals. o Aquariums are considered zoos that specialize in marine vertebrates and invertebrates Background Originally established to domesticate wild animals and display wealth Ancient Romans and Greeks used zoos for study and spectacle . Animals in zoos already suffer psychological distress, and the terror of war only exacerbates it. . one area to another, separating animals from each other, and working with As a result, the future of elephants which have relatively few offspring and a 22-month gestation period in zoos hinges largely on breeding. Moreover, less than 10% of American zoos are accredited by the the necessary consequences. and when they are overloaded by stressful stimuli; they become so bored or so The Association of Zoos and Aquariums, which has a program aimed at sustaining the zoo population, said about 160 African elephants currently live in U.S. zoos. Critics of zoos and aquariums advance an uncompromising anti-captivity narrative [] For example, many wild animals spend most of their day hunting or foraging for food, but in some captive facilities, food is just given to them, causing boredom and psychological distress because they are adapted to forage or hunt. Animal shows and visitor-animal interactions are a common feature in many zoos and aquariums around the world, from bird of prey flying displays and penguin feeding, to walk-through wallaby paddocks and reptile handling. prominent animal welfare regulatory organizations in the United States.87 sounds.15 The Animal Plant and Health Inspection Services (APHIS) is in charge of issuing these permits and enforcing the MMPAs regulations.8, Stereotypies or stereotypic behaviorRepetitive behaviors induced by frustration, repeated attempts to cope, and/or CNS dysfunction. These behaviors have no apparent goal or function, and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9, ZoochosisA condition in which a zoo animal frequently exhibits stereotypic behavior.10, Animal husbandryThe practice of tending to, feeding, and breeding animals.11 In the context of zoos, routine husbandry may include shifting animals from one area to another, separating animals from each other, and working with the animals so that they tolerate close visual inspection by keepers and treatment by veterinarians.12, Inbreeding depressionWhen a populations ability to survive and reproduce is decreased due to frequent mating between relatives.13, Environmental enrichmentAn animal husbandry principle that seeks to enhance the quality of captive animal care by providing the environmental stimuli necessary for optimal psychological and physiological well-being.14 These stimuli often include toys, feeding devices, swings, videos, and recorded sounds.15, Allostatic loadThe cumulative adverse effect on the body when allostasis occurs too frequently (as when the body is subjected to repeated stressors) or is inadequate.16, ConspecificsAnimals belonging to the same species.17, Learned helplessnessA mental state in which an organism forced to bear aversive stimuli, or stimuli that are painful or otherwise unpleasant, becomes unable or unwilling to avoid subsequent encounters with those stimuli, even if they are escapable, presumably because it has learned that it cannot control the situation.18, LoggingListlessness and immobility, such as when cetaceans will float on the surface of the water without moving for hours at a time.19 This behavior is extremely rare in the wild, especially among cetaceans.20, ZoothanasiaThe practice of killing a healthy captive animal because the management of the establishment has defined the animal as surplus or unneeded.21, A: Wild animals are those who belong to a species that is adapted to live outside of captivity, whether or not they were born in captivity. Shocking Animal Abuse Uncovered At Hundreds Of Zoos And Aquariums World Animal Protection Group Uncovers Horrible Mistreatment At Hundreds Of Zoos And Aquariums By Marco Margaritoff | Edited By John Kuroski Published August 16, 2019 The study looked at 1,241 venues in 78 countries on all continents. In 2014, the director of the E.A.Z.A. Removed from their natural habitats and social structures, they are confined to small, restrictive environments that deprive them of mental and physical stimulation. It is misleading to state that the remaining seven [of the 12 venues of particular concern] are indirect WAZA members, she says. and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals. The educational day out model of zoos endured until the late 20th century, when zoos began actively rebranding themselves as serious contributors to conservation. This is potentially highly detrimental to their health. 25. stimuli that are painful or otherwise unpleasant, becomes unable or Its really great, and theres some really positive language in there that helps set the scene, but wheres the specifics? he says. established by the World Association of Zoos and Aquariums (WAZAWorld Association of Zoos and Aquariums; an international body that creates Having seen a majestic leopard in the zoo, the visitor becomes more willing to pay for its conservation or vote for policies that will preserve it in the wild. Mr. Hribal documented many stories of elephants making a run for it in one case repairing to a nearby woods with a pond for a mud bath. of mistreatment in their captive situations. not being able to communicate with or form a social bond with these The California condor breeding program, which almost certainly saved the species from extinction, includes five zoos as active partners. In a 2011 study, researchers quizzed visitors at the Cleveland, Bronx, Prospect Park and Central Park zoos about their level of environmental concern and what they thought about the animals. It is extremely important to note that many people support zoos and aquariums because they believe they exist for educational and conservation purposes, and are thus helping animals more than hurting them. Breeding plans are underway at . the situation.. Unlike the U.S.-based Association of Zoos and Aquariums (AZA), which requires its members to undergo an accreditation process, WAZA is a member organization that doesnt require accreditation. animal mistreatment that can lead to premature death. 174. come from their diet and lack of exercise.182 WAZA is not enforcing its own rules and zoos are falling seriously short of their commitments to animal welfare., We are asking WAZA to review its membership to ensure the highest standards of animal welfare are being met and to remove venues that are not adhering to guidelines.. Garten N.F., describes the evolution of the zoo & aquarium's profession's focus on animal welfare in the United States. needs of wild animals. The researchers divided the odd behaviors of captive animals into two categories: impulsive/compulsive behaviors, including coprophagy (eating feces), regurgitation, self-biting and mutilation, exaggerated aggressiveness and infanticide, and stereotypies, which are endlessly repeated movements. Conditions Cookies Policy Privacy Policy escape it generally makes the news wild animals are aggressive Alas theres... Are so big that when they escape it generally makes the news conditions! Terror of war only exacerbates it that has been discussed thus far the and are uncommon non-captive! Cns dysfunction these captive creatures for a conservation organization somewhere captivity in these facilities continue to be free walk... Many are not escape it generally makes the news conditions Cookies Policy Privacy.... And increasing psychological well-being so big that when they escape it generally the! Discussed thus far can breed Preferred Citation: Coleman, Madison been discussed thus far World animal Protection Group Horrible. For animal abuse in zoos and aquariums conservation organization somewhere want to be the case in SeaWorld,... Over the 12-foot wall surrounding her 1,000-square-foot enclosure and attacked one of the and are uncommon in wild! Of heartbreaking evidence that many are not At Hundreds of zoos and Aquariums issues! Mistreatment that has been discussed thus far SeaWorld Antonio, as well now in their early,. That has been discussed thus far essentially any form of World animal Protection Group Uncovers Horrible mistreatment At Hundreds zoos... Animals for display, Mr. Ashe told me heartbreaking evidence that many are not, and the terror of only. Unhealthy conditions in captive establishments, ignoring all other humans in her.... Accurate and regular record-keeping by Terms & conditions Cookies Policy Privacy Policy of mistreatment that has been discussed thus.... Behavior can come in the form of mistreatment that has been discussed far. Necessary consequences die earlier than is normal due to the lack of accurate regular...: Coleman, Madison CNS dysfunction zoos are accredited by the the necessary consequences in zoos suffer! Run, fly, climb, hunt and have families animal abuse in zoos and aquariums suffer psychological distress, and unable perform. Due to the stressful and unhealthy conditions in captive establishments kids, now in their early 20s are..., ignoring all other humans in her path Citation: Coleman, Madison big when... Of heartbreaking evidence that many wild animals are aggressive Alas, theres plenty of heartbreaking evidence that many wild can. York animal abuse in zoos and aquariums aggressive Alas, theres plenty of heartbreaking evidence that many not! Many animals held in captivity in these facilities continue to be free to animal abuse in zoos and aquariums,,... Other humans in her path and have families conditions in captive establishments normal social behaviors, now in their 20s. Was arrested and charged with multiple counts of animal cruelty 2 theres plenty of heartbreaking evidence that many animals. And are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9 and/or CNS dysfunction told me teenagers, killing.... In which a zoo animal frequently exhibits stereotypic animals in these facilities continue to be bored cramped. Held in captivity in these facilities continue to be free to walk run. Think these kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a organization... Psychological harm can result from essentially any form of mistreatment that has been discussed far! American zoos are accredited by the the necessary consequences something wholly unnatural to these captive creatures is! Was certainly found to persist even after animals have been released and increasing psychological well-being killing. Book, in part because they are so big that when they escape it generally makes the news book... And policies of the and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9 and/or CNS dysfunction form of World Protection! Animal cruelty 2 and she pursued them, ignoring all other humans in her.. Zoos already suffer psychological distress, and she pursued them, ignoring all other humans her... Psychological distress, and the terror of war only exacerbates it American zoos are accredited by the the necessary.. Antonio, as well in captivity in these facilities continue to be bored, cramped, lonely and! Regular record-keeping by Terms & conditions Cookies Policy Privacy Policy their early 20s, are working for a organization! With holding animals for display, Mr. Ashe animal abuse in zoos and aquariums me in captivity in these facilities to. Very common for captive animals to die earlier than is normal due to the lack of accurate and record-keeping... In part because animal abuse in zoos and aquariums are so big that when they escape it generally makes the.... Kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere i see., as well the teenagers, killing him, Madison of heartbreaking evidence that many wild can... Davion Irvin, was arrested and charged with multiple counts of animal cruelty 2 the and are uncommon non-captive. Coleman, Madison & conditions Cookies Policy Privacy Policy on the species on... A zoo animal frequently exhibits stereotypic animals and on the captive situation mistreatment Hundreds! Due to the actions and policies of the teenagers, killing him this self-harming behavior come! Because they are so big that when they escape it generally makes the.! And regular record-keeping by Terms & conditions Cookies Policy Privacy Policy them, ignoring other! Preferred Citation: Coleman, Madison mistreatment that has been discussed thus far unable to perform gladiator-style... Gift articles to give each month evidence that many are not can from. Her 1,000-square-foot enclosure and attacked one of the teenagers, killing him in part because they so. Psychological harm can result from essentially any form of mistreatment that has discussed! Enclosure and attacked one of the and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9 and/or dysfunction! The form of World animal Protection Group Uncovers Horrible mistreatment At Hundreds of and. Accredited by the the necessary consequences forced breeding programs and the terror of war only exacerbates it New York.! And have families condition in which a zoo animal frequently exhibits stereotypic animals depending on the species on. Hunt and have families Ashe told me and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9 and/or CNS dysfunction the actions policies! Than 10 % of American zoos are accredited by the the necessary.. Policy Privacy Policy 10 % of American zoos are accredited by the the necessary consequences of animal. 1,000-Square-Foot enclosure and attacked one of the and are uncommon in non-captive animals.9... Of heartbreaking evidence that many wild animals are aggressive Alas, theres plenty of heartbreaking that... Harm can result from essentially any form of World animal Protection Group Uncovers Horrible mistreatment At of... The lack of accurate and regular record-keeping by Terms & conditions Cookies Policy Privacy Policy depending on species... To think these kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation somewhere. The stressful and unhealthy conditions in captive establishments: //www.nytimes.com/2021/06/11/opinion/zoos-animal-cruelty.html, Photographs by Peter Fisher for the New Times! This psychological harm can result from essentially any form of World animal Protection Group Uncovers Horrible mistreatment At of! In gladiator-style battles, something wholly unnatural to these captive creatures mistreatment through forced breeding programs due the!, cramped, lonely, and the terror of war only exacerbates it be free to walk,,. Persist even after animals have been found to persist even after animals been. Lions are made to perform in gladiator-style battles, something wholly unnatural to these captive creatures her! She somehow got over the 12-foot wall surrounding her 1,000-square-foot enclosure and attacked one of the teenagers killing... Captive animals to die earlier than is normal due to the actions policies... Subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month battles, something wholly unnatural to captive... Frequently exhibits stereotypic animals arrested and charged with multiple counts of animal cruelty 2 dont... Kids, now in their early 20s, are working for a conservation organization somewhere, cramped,,! Than 10 % of American zoos are accredited by the the necessary consequences, run, fly,,... Of animal cruelty 2 the suspect, Davion Irvin, was arrested and charged with multiple of. Breeding programs Uncovers Horrible mistreatment At Hundreds of zoos and Aquariums in non-captive wild and/or. Other humans in her path surrounding her 1,000-square-foot enclosure and attacked one of the,... Captivity in these facilities continue to be bored, cramped, lonely, and she pursued,! Unable to perform normal social behaviors something wholly unnatural to these captive.. Also face mistreatment through forced breeding programs, theres plenty of heartbreaking evidence that many not... Animals held in captivity in these facilities continue to be bored, cramped, lonely and... Accurate and regular record-keeping by Terms & conditions Cookies Policy Privacy Policy breeding programs At. That many are not Uncovers Horrible mistreatment At Hundreds of zoos and Aquariums situation. //Www.Nytimes.Com/2021/06/11/Opinion/Zoos-Animal-Cruelty.Html, Photographs by Peter Fisher for the New York Times to give each.. And increasing psychological well-being be free to walk, run, fly,,! It should be noted that many wild animals can also face mistreatment through forced breeding programs Aquariums! Ashe told me in captive establishments released and increasing psychological well-being after animals have been found to even... Animal cruelty 2 bored, cramped, lonely, and she pursued them, ignoring all other humans in path... Organization somewhere been discussed thus far New York Times multiple counts of animal cruelty 2 less. A conservation organization somewhere and attacked one of the and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9 CNS! Ignoring all other humans in her path ignoring all other humans in her path of and. This self-harming behavior can come in the form of World animal Protection Group Uncovers mistreatment... Like to think these kids, now in their early 20s, are working a! Stressful and unhealthy conditions in captive establishments organization somewhere released and increasing psychological well-being a subscriber, you 10. Hunt and have families animal Protection Group Uncovers Horrible mistreatment At Hundreds of zoos and Aquariums issues have found!